from iturnedintoanewt@lemmy.world to selfhosted@lemmy.world on 26 Jun 04:05
https://lemmy.world/post/48654094
So…this is very tangentially related to Self Hosting, but hear me out…
We travel frequently, either for work or leisure. As a self-hoster, I always bring an Nvidia shield player on my travel bag, to connect to my Jellyfin host from whichever hotel we might be staying at, to watch at night for example.
But increasingly, this is becoming a pain in the butt. As most TVs aren’t directly hooked anymore to just the antenna or the hotel’s connection. No, they usually will be hooked to an Android box handling all sorts of crap, from the hotel welcoming screens to some info, to their pre-set channels. And the android remote works via HDMI-ARC to control the TV, of which they usually hide the damn OEM remote. So, if you unplug their android box to hook up your own player, you lose the TV controls. In some cases (Sony, mostly) you might be in luck finding the 3 physical buttons they include somewhere on the TV itself to navigate inputs and volume. But in some others, you might as well end up stuck in an Android app menu where you can’t get out (I’m looking at you Phillips). So I think my next addition would be to get an universal remote to sort all these quirks when traveling. Anyone else went through these considerations? Any recommendations?
#selfhosted
threaded - newest
perhaps something like a Sofabaton U2 would do well for you? you can put in a device preset for the shield and for your home devices plus anything else you need, but also pull a codeset for the hotel TV and swap it out as needed from their app when travelling. you rarely need exact model number matches, usually just something from the right era from the right manufacturer gets you all the commands you need. Add a Flirc USB to use IR on the shield with more control (or on shields without built in IR), you can use any IR codes then, and map keyboard macros and such, or use the sofabatons built in Bluetooth support for a native remote.
Nothing selfhostable in that regard, and most of the solutions that do exist are either terribly tedious, or rely on chinese server at some point.
Outside of that, i’m playing with an Astrion remote at home at the moment, which also uses Chinese servers, but you can block all of that and connect it directly to home assistant. it’s far from perfect and a lot of features are still in the development timeline, but they are keeping their word so far with version drops, and the majority of the code is public on their github. Hardly an option for travelling with though.
Thanks. I’ve been looking to a proper remote to carry the torch of the Logitech Harmony. This seems like a great package
The sofabatons are imperfect, but they’re as close to harmony as you will get
I checked some reviews to see how they operate. It looks like the main difference is that the Sofabaton does not have “activities” where the remote keeps track of the state of a device. That is a bit of a shame, but other than that is seems like a pretty close match.
The U2, which is the one that is portable, I.e. no base station, doesn’t have activities, but you can fudge activity behaviour with macros. Its handy to just throw some codes onto it from the app and go.
The x1s and X do have activities but they are more expensive and need a base station.
I’d love it if they’d release a base station-less version with activity capability. I see no reason why that wouldn’t be possible (other than potentially cannibalising their own sales with a cheaper and similarly capable model)
Flipper zero.
At the very least it has built-in universal power, volume, channel, and maybe some other buttons. Now that I think about it though, I bet I could make a companion app so your phone acts like the TV remote and sends the signal over the flipper via Bluetooth.
Plus you can store your hotel key, garage remote, and who knows what else in it. It’s a really cool little tool to have.
This is why I want one of these little motherfuckers so god damned badly.
I’m so glad that none of it’s components have been hit hard by the AI tech market disaster, price point still the same so far. (crossing fingers for it to stay the same)
It has gone up $30, which isn’t so bad relatively.
It’s still $199 for me, which is the price I remember it being for a few years now but maybe I am wrong.
Yeah it started at $169
The FLIRC Skip 1S might be your best option. The software for it is a little finicky but you can program the volume button up/down to fire multiple volume commands. One button press could control a bunch of different TV brand volumes.
I’m not sure if it can control the shield, but you may be able to program it.
Some phones come with an infrared (IR) blaster. Check the specs of your phone and just use that if it has one.
Yeah theres universal remote aops to take advantage of the IR blaster in phones
A year ago I replaced my Logitech Harmony Elite with a SofaBaton X1S, and I have no regrets. The SofaBaton is much more reliable than the Logitech was. The Harmony remote would sometimes unpair itself from the Nvida Shield I was using.
I appreciate a hub based remote might not be ideal for travelling. But there’s not doubt other models that might be suitable.
random LG or Xiaomi android phone. they have ir blaster built in.
at least on my LG G2 it works even after installing a custom rom (lineageos)
A screen is always a significantly worse experience than physical programmable buttons sadly
true, but this is a real “universal” remote so…
the xiaomi ir remote app (proprietary ofc) has presets for basically anything i ever needed a remote for. i have it on my primary phone so it has saved me on a few occasions.
Visit the play store
What about the shields own Cec option? Has it not worked when plugging it in instead of the host’s android boxes?
I bought a Sofabaton U2 to replace my worn-out Harmony and it’s… okay. The main frustration is the buttons. You really have to mash them to get them to register, and way the remote is designed the IR signal gets weaker as the batteries fade, which can be really frustrating. The wheel that chooses your program has also become very flaky.
That said, the app for programming it is better than Logitec’s for the Harmony. If you’re in there frequently to set up control of different hotel TVs it should be fairly easy.