Cursor is better at marketing than coding (www.theregister.com)
from brianpeiris@lemmy.ca to programming@programming.dev on 27 Jan 17:09
https://lemmy.ca/post/59375085

AI-integrated development environment (IDE) company Cursor recently implied it had built a working web browser almost entirely with its AI agents. I won’t say they lied, but CEO Michael Truell certainly tweeted: “We built a browser with GPT-5.2 in Cursor.”

He followed up with: “It’s 3M+ lines of code across thousands of files. The rendering engine is from-scratch in Rust with HTML parsing, CSS cascade, layout, text shaping, paint, and a custom JS VM.”

That sounds impressive, doesn’t it? He also added: “It kind of works,” which is not the most ringing endorsement…

Too bad it wasn’t true. If you actually looked at Cursor engineer Wilson Lin’s blog post about FastRender, the AI-created web browser, you won’t see much boasting about a working web browser. Instead, there’s a video of a web browser sort of working, and a much less positive note that “building a browser from scratch is extremely difficult.”

Developers quickly discovered the “browser” barely compiles, often does not run, and was heavily misrepresented in marketing.

…this week‑long autonomous browser experiment consumed in the order of 10-20 trillion tokens and would have cost several million dollars at then‑current list prices for frontier models.

#programming

threaded - newest

[deleted] on 27 Jan 17:34 next collapse
.
MonkderVierte@lemmy.zip on 27 Jan 17:36 next collapse

The rendering engine is from-scratch in Rust

That’s a lie. LLM don’t do “from scratch”.

And Heise (german IT-newspaper) tested it too: crashes on X, a bit less on wayland, urlbar sometimes not working, scrolling neither, stuff like that. In short, it’s crap.

GammaGames@beehaw.org on 27 Jan 17:39 next collapse

It’s a double lie! It also uses a bunch of rust libraries

9point6@lemmy.world on 27 Jan 17:40 next collapse

Yeah I was gonna say, how much similarity is there with servo?

wischi@programming.dev on 27 Jan 19:32 collapse

But to be fair nobody does anything from scratch. Most people were in school at least for a few years. If you code, you’ve probably read a lot of code and documentation, if you draw you probably saw a lot of drawings, if you play chess you probably studied a lot of different games.

LodeMike@lemmy.today on 27 Jan 17:57 next collapse

Cursor? I hardly know er!!

ulterno@programming.dev on 27 Jan 18:12 collapse

Title made me feel like it will do the marketing for me, so I can freelance instead of having to go to some stinky office.
Such a let down.