ELI5 why I logically understand McDonald's food is low quality and bad for me but I crave it like crack?
from TheReanuKeeves@lemmy.world to nostupidquestions@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 12:08
https://lemmy.world/post/39754447

#nostupidquestions

threaded - newest

RobotToaster@mander.xyz on 05 Dec 12:12 next collapse

The same reason people will logically understand that crack is bad for them but crave it like crack

Magister@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 12:32 next collapse
prettybunnys@piefed.social on 05 Dec 13:44 collapse

This is actually shockingly remarkably true.

There is very little to differentiate your addiction to junk food and your addiction to sex or your addiction to crack rock.

6nk06@sh.itjust.works on 05 Dec 12:12 next collapse

Grease, sugar, and a lot of chemicals.

JohnnyEnzyme@piefed.social on 05 Dec 13:02 next collapse

Don’t forget loads of salt!

Like– every step of the way, fast food places have an opportunity to aim for ‘healthier’ or ‘more delicious’ choices, overwhelmingly with profit-making in mind. That’s the main thing to keep in mind.

IIRC, McD’s and various other chains even design venting and such to get the smell of the cooking food (chemically enhanced) in to the surrounding area. You know, so that more people can pay a fortune to get a food rush that doubles as a health disaster.

SaveTheTuaHawk@lemmy.ca on 05 Dec 14:23 collapse

McDonald’s smells like a dirty deep fryer, it’s fucking disgusting.

imsufferableninja@sh.itjust.works on 05 Dec 14:23 collapse

Everything is a chemical

amino@lemmy.blahaj.zone on 05 Dec 12:32 next collapse

fast food isn’t bad for you, unless you only eat only fast food for years. if you wanna recreate the MCD taste at home, try sprinkling MSG on your food.

Asetru@feddit.org on 05 Dec 12:51 next collapse

Do I look like I know what an MSG is?

474D@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 13:02 next collapse

You can buy it in a bottle like spices. It looks like salt. I like to replace the regular amount of salt with 50% msg and 50% salt when cooking

bonenode@piefed.social on 05 Dec 13:07 next collapse

Monosodium glutamat

MyTurtleSwimsUpsideDown@fedia.io on 05 Dec 13:20 collapse

Now I want a doormat with “monosodium gluta” inscribed on it

lemmyknow@lemmy.today on 05 Dec 13:31 next collapse

MSG king of flawor (or so I hear)

SuiXi3D@fedia.io on 05 Dec 13:35 collapse

Just go to the grocery store and buy some?

flamiera@kbin.melroy.org on 05 Dec 13:48 collapse

In moderation, yes. But, the calories is ridiculous if you follow a 2,000 calorie diet.

Hotcakes and Sausage should not be 770 calories. I've bought frozen sausage links that give me 100 calories for just 2 links of sausages. Store-bought food are more sensitivity to calories than any fast food joint is.

Fast Food and even Buffet Restaurants are good for when you've eaten nothing for a while and you need something filling. They aren't good for daily intake. They're barely okay for once a week. But they're not meant to be your daily meals.

amino@lemmy.blahaj.zone on 06 Dec 15:06 collapse

fun fact, the 2k calorie diet is absolute bullshit and the FDA themselves said it shouldn’t be taken as “anything over this threshold is bad”.

They aren’t good for daily intake

says who? if fast food is the only food you can afford and you don’t own a kitchen, that is the healthier option to take because the alternative is starving.

But they’re not meant to be your daily meals.

Humans also weren’t meant to work 2 jobs and 14 hour days and yet living under capitalism, your diet adapts to your environment in order to help you make it to the next day.

flamiera@kbin.melroy.org on 06 Dec 16:00 collapse

if fast food is the only food you can afford and you don't own a kitchen, that is the healthier option to take because the alternative is starving.

What do you mean you can't buy an electric burner? What do you mean you can't cook even something as basic as a mac and cheese dinner meal? What do you mean you can't simply just look up how to cook things? I don't understand! null

Humans also weren't meant to work 2 jobs and 14 hour days and yet living under capitalism, your diet adapts to your environment in order to help you make it to the next day.

Excuses, excuses.

fun fact, the 2k calorie diet is absolute bullshit and the FDA themselves said it shouldn't be taken as "anything over this threshold is bad".

Take the tinfoil hat off, timmy.

amino@lemmy.blahaj.zone on 06 Dec 16:03 collapse

What do you mean you can’t buy an electric burner? What do you mean you can’t cook even something as basic as a mac and cheese dinner meal? What do you mean you can’t simply just look up how to cook things? I don’t understand! null

how many homeless people have you given cash to so they can fulfill your fantasy of living a healthy upstanding citizen’s lifestyle? do you give out hot meals to people in need? if not, stfu and stop being sinful by judging people in need

Manjushri@piefed.social on 05 Dec 12:33 next collapse

There is a chemical in your brain called dopamine which is an important part of how we feel pleasure. Use of recreational drugs and alcohol causes a rush of this chemical and that is part of the pleasure we feel from using them. The problem is that regular use of such chemicals causes us to have lower levels of dopamine when we are not using them. We end up feeling a desire for the drug or booze to get our dopamine levels back up.

Diets high in sugar, salt, and carbs also causes a dopamine rush. When you eat that food regularly, it lowers your normal dopamine levels, just like drugs and alcohol do, if not to the same level. That is why you feel that craving. Eating such food occasionally is fine, but if you do it to often, you can literally get an addiction to it.

Edit to add -

You mentioned that fast foods are low quality and bad for you. That is true, but but only in high quantities. Fats and sugars were high value foods to our ancient ancestors. Fats are very high source of energy. You get more than twice the energy from a gram of fat than you get from a gram of carbohydrates or protein. Sugars are easily digested making them a source of quick energy compared to other carbs, fats, or proteins. Eating these kinds of foods gave us a survival advantage over those who didn’t, at least until we learned the agricultural skills to make them easy to acquire. Now, many or most people can get such foods any time they want and though they no longer give us an advantage, and eating a lot of them is actually harmful in the long run, those ancient taste preferences still remain in our evolved programing.

Skullgrid@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 13:14 next collapse

based middle of the road, analytical, truthful and realistic take.

TomMasz@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 13:18 next collapse

We evolved for a life of scarcity, but now we live in a world of plenty.

Venator@lemmy.nz on 06 Dec 11:01 next collapse

Therefore, the cure for fast food addiction is recreational drugs and alcohol!

Manjushri@piefed.social on 06 Dec 12:58 collapse

RFK, is that you?

SaveTheTuaHawk@lemmy.ca on 11 Dec 13:53 collapse

Overactivate dopamine receptors and the receptors shut down, like all receptors. Lack of dopamine signalling is Parkinson’s disease.

JoMiran@lemmy.ml on 05 Dec 13:12 next collapse

A very large culprit is your gut’s microbiome (the bacteria that live in our gut). The more junk food you eat, the more you will grow your craving for it.

psychologytoday.com/…/where-cravings-are-bred

masterspace@lemmy.ca on 05 Dec 14:24 next collapse

Because we didn’t evolve to live in lands of abundance. We evolved in scarce conditions and are attuned to that.

Food that delicious and high calorie would not be constantly available in the wild, so if we ever found anything close, it would be beneficial to eat as much as possible to store up calories and survive during periods of scarcity.

Devial@discuss.online on 05 Dec 14:31 next collapse

Because fat and sugar are drugs. People don’t usually think of them like drugs, because of the widely accepted, but very wrong, attitude that only illegal substances can be drugs. Sugar, fat, caffeine, alcohol or tobacco are all drugs. They all trigger a desirable chemical reaction in your brain, and all have addictive potential. At least 2 or 3 of them are also significantly more harmful to you than several types of actually illegal drugs.

And in general, though perhaps most strongly for drugs, many people suffer from the cognitive bias of “illegal=bad & legal=good. Automatically and by default”

Aspharr@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 15:54 collapse

I get the spirit of what you’re saying, they’re all habit forming, but fat and sugar (IE: carbohydrates) are macronutrients our bodies need to survive. Obviously they’re not needed in the quantities that are available to us in modern society, but our biological desire to seek out high calorie foods is a survival mechanism rather than what happens with other habit forming substances like tobacco.

I don’t mean to nitpick here but I feel like that distinction is important because saying “sugar and fat bad” without a little nuance can miss lead folks that aren’t properly educated on nutrition, which in my experience is a large portion of my fellow Americans.

Edit: just wanted to add here that there’s another comment by someone else who more or less states the same thing, but makes that distinction and I have no problem with it.

inb4_FoundTheVegan@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 16:01 next collapse

Because sugar, fat and salt in those quantities are literally addictive. Our human/monkey brains were wired for survival, not overall health. Eating a large source of those three would’ve been a massive help in surviving winter when our next meal wouldn’t be guaranteed.

theneverfox@pawb.social on 05 Dec 15:38 next collapse

Because your diet sucks. A few months of eating only unprocessed food and you’d probably eat McDonald’s exactly one more time in your life

And I do specifically mean McDonald’s… It’s uniquely disgusting, even among fast food. It tastes like it’s reconstituted food scraps doped with sugar

paraphrand@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 16:04 next collapse

As someone who is trying to climb out of this hole, I can back up your sentiment.

Being acclimated to shitty food, and thinking flavor is just sharp strong sensations in your mouth is one thing that perpetuates over consuming fast food. Your brain gets trained to crave the dopamine rush that the sensations of fast food briefly cause.

starlinguk@lemmy.world on 13 Dec 19:15 collapse

It’s amazing how you can eat 12 chicken nuggets with large fries and still feel like you haven’t eaten anything.

theneverfox@pawb.social on 13 Dec 22:10 collapse

Oh, I’d feel nauseous lol, those nuggets are so gross and I don’t really like the fries

Corporal_Punishment@feddit.uk on 05 Dec 16:48 next collapse

Want to experience the ultimate in shitty comfort food?

Come to the UK, go into town, have a few beers, get drunk and then stop for a massive dirty kebab on the way home.

Fucking bliss

xvertigox@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 19:30 collapse

Curry on chips is A+ too

hungprocess@thriv.social on 05 Dec 20:37 next collapse

“Because he puts an addictive chemical in his chicken that makes ya crave it fortnightly, smart arse!"
<img alt="" src="https://thriv-media.thriv.social/posts/GM/rw/GMrwKrXYQKtgAnn.jpeg">

dickalan@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 00:38 collapse

Is that Mike Myers? I still haven’t seen so I married an ax murderer even though I own it

Yes it is. lol

Colonel Sanders

Pat_Riot@lemmy.today on 07 Dec 15:09 collapse

Why deprive yourself so? It’s easily my favorite Myers film.

dickalan@lemmy.world on 07 Dec 20:37 collapse

I know and I’m a huge fan of Mike Myers but once I watch it I can’t un Watch it so it’s like I’m saving it for a bad day when I need to be cheered up. But you’re right tomorrow is not promised, I should make hay while the sun is out

SkyNTP@lemmy.ml on 05 Dec 18:23 next collapse

You crave salt and fat because your body needs a little bit of these things to survive, but finding salt and fat out in nature is really really hard, so those cavemen that liked the taste of salty or fatty foods enough to make the extra effort to find those foods were more likely to survive to be your ancestors and you inherited that behaviour. That’s why you like McDonald’s, it’s full of the salt and fat that is hard to obtain if your diet consists of mostly roots and mushrooms and leaves.

McDonalds is bad for you because it’s unnaturally full of salt and fat. Far, far more than your body needs and far more than your cavemen ancestors would have eaten naturally. Especially if you eat McDonald’s often. Too much of anything turns that thing into a poison.

McDonald’s has only been around a generation or two. That’s not enough time for the people who crave McDonalds and eat too much of it to die off, leaving mostly people who don’t crave McDonalds to remain.

painteddoggie@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 23:09 collapse

They would have to die off before they reproduce

essell@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 23:41 collapse

Or if they produced Infertile Offspring.

olafurp@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 14:37 next collapse

It’s science, I don’t know the specifics of craving but I know they spent a lot of money to figure out how give you that feeling.

BlushedPotatoPlayers@sopuli.xyz on 07 Dec 13:44 collapse

I’d guess sugar and fat, lots of both

olafurp@lemmy.world on 07 Dec 16:10 collapse

I know about a funky thing where if you have equal amounts of sweet, salty, bitter, umami and sour you feel less full after eating it. It might be completely unrelated though.

toynbee@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 17:04 next collapse

When I was a kid, I heard two unsubstantiated rumors about McDonald’s food:

  1. It used kangaroo meat (not sure why this was a claim)
  2. It mixed in nicotine (to make the food more addictive)

I doubt that either are true, but if the latter were maybe it would answer your question.

olafurp@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 14:38 next collapse

Pretty sure you’d have to label nicotine content and age restrict it no matter how it’s consumed.

toynbee@lemmy.world on 07 Dec 10:52 collapse

Agreed, but I don’t think the urban legend was claiming that they were doing this legitimately.

AngryCommieKender@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 17:12 collapse

They don’t mix in nicotine, no need for all of that when MSG exists. They do mix in MSG to the meats and cheeses. Pretty much all fast food does, because it makes it addictive, and tasty.

toynbee@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 17:15 collapse

When I was a kid, I don’t think I knew what MSG was, so this reasoning would have been lost on me.

AngryCommieKender@lemmy.world on 05 Dec 17:17 collapse

When I was a kid the racist “MSG in Chinese food” panic was happening. I knew about Chinese salt when I started cooking around 6 or 7

SaveTheTuaHawk@lemmy.ca on 11 Dec 13:49 collapse

Having a reaction to a food additive is not racist. You are parroting the bots spread forth by a $7B industry. MSG reaction is real. Do we call people who get food allergies racist?

AngryCommieKender@lemmy.world on 11 Dec 14:55 collapse

Yet, everyone I know that had so called reactions to MSG in Chinese food could eat Pizza Hut and McDonald’s which both use MSG and they never had a ‘reaction.’

They also haven’t complained about MSG since the late '80s. There may be some people that have an actual allergy to MSG, but I have yet to meet one, and I have a much higher sampling of people to pull from than most.

chunes@lemmy.world on 07 Dec 11:16 next collapse

You haven’t aged enough to where it feels like you have a rat trying to chew through your colon from the inside out when you eat it. That will cure you of the addiction right quick.

leftzero@lemmy.dbzer0.com on 05 Dec 14:52 collapse

I don’t get it.

I’ve tried McDonalds food.

It’s more expensive than much better alternatives, it doesn’t look good, and it tastes worse, like the cheapest ultraprocessed crap you can find in the kind of budget supermarket that only carries foreign brands you’ve never heard of.

I can find better and cheaper food in seedy bars I’d never willingly go to, or by buying the cheapest brands (even the good brands or fast food joints, or buying natural ingredients, wouldn’t be significantly more expensive) and cooking at home.

It really boggles my mind. Is it like smoking? Do people start eating it due to peer pressure and never stop because they get addicted?

SaveTheTuaHawk@lemmy.ca on 11 Dec 13:51 collapse

Advertising and peer pressure as teens.

You could feed a family of 4 for a week on the cost. It has no nutritive value in addition to no flavor. It’s like some type of dystopian government food paste.